Is it rational to believe in miracles?

Episode 2 • August 08, 2025 • 01:40:22
Is it rational to believe in miracles?
Questioning Belief
Is it rational to believe in miracles?

Aug 08 2025 | 01:40:22

/

Show Notes

How can it ever be reasonable to accept the testimonial evidence of an alleged miracle over the mass of evidence that the natural world behaves according to the laws of nature? Could it be rational to accept that miracles could theoretically occur, or are miracles impossible violations of nature? Dr. Timothy McGrew discusses the history of objections to miracles, focusing on Hume and Spinoza, and puts forth positive and negative criteria for evaluating the evidence behind a miracle claim. We discuss the evidence for miracle claims from the Bible, from Catholicism (Eucharistic miracles and the healings at Lourdes), and from religions other than Christianity. We conclude with a personal testimony on how to remain faithful to God in the face of unanswered prayers and undelivered miracles.

The Questioning Belief podcast, hosted by Kathleen Milani, Ph.D., addresses objections to Christianity through in-depth discussions with experts. Drawing from her background as a former atheist and her experience in apologetics, Kathleen invites you to explore thoughtful responses to serious questions about faith. Learn more at: www.cslewisinstitute.org/questioning-belief

Other Episodes

Episode 21

May 15, 2026 • 00:59:39
Episode Cover

Forgiveness in a Broken World with Amy Orr-Ewing

Prominent theologian Dr. Amy Orr-Ewing joins us to discuss her new book, Forgiveness: Reclaiming its Power in a Culture of Outrage and Fear. We...

Listen

Episode 20

April 17, 2026 • 01:25:56
Episode Cover

Intellectual Property: Creativity and Ownership in Law and the Bible

Is it appropriate-- or even relevant-- to bring principles of one's Christian faith into the workplace? We address this question in the field of...

Listen

Episode 6

October 03, 2025 • 01:13:15
Episode Cover

Natural Evil: how can a good and powerful God allow natural disasters and disease?

Sharon Dirckx, PhD., trained neuroscientist, prolific speaker, and author of award-winning books on the problem of evil and human consciousness, helps us to tackle...

Listen