The Gospel of John: Historically Accurate or Highly Embellished?

Episode 16 February 20, 2026 01:38:32
The Gospel of John: Historically Accurate or Highly Embellished?
Questioning Belief
The Gospel of John: Historically Accurate or Highly Embellished?

Feb 20 2026 | 01:38:32

/

Show Notes

You may or may not be aware of the debates surrounding the historicity of the Gospel of John. Many scholars have suggested that John’s Gospel contains unhistorical embellishments or is “metaphorically” but not historically true as are Matthew, Mark, and Luke. This accusation has serious implications for our understanding of Jesus and His teachings, as well as for the reliability of the New Testament as a whole. Did John truly alter the facts and put words in Jesus’ mouth to serve his own theological goals? Analytic philosopher Lydia McGrew refutes these claims in The Eye of the Beholder: The Gospel of John as Historical Reportage, arguing in detail that John never invents material and that he is robustly reliable and honestly historical.

Resources:

Other Episodes

Episode 3

August 22, 2025 00:51:29
Episode Cover

Christian Literature and the Numinous: Storytelling, Myths, and Re-enchantment

Dr. Carolyn Weber, a prolific writer, professor of literature, and ardent Christian, joins us to discuss the rich history of Christian literature and the...

Listen

Episode 21

May 15, 2026 00:59:39
Episode Cover

Forgiveness in a Broken World with Amy Orr-Ewing

Prominent theologian Dr. Amy Orr-Ewing joins us to discuss her new book, Forgiveness: Reclaiming its Power in a Culture of Outrage and Fear. We...

Listen

Episode 1

July 17, 2025 01:02:15
Episode Cover

The Problem of Pain with Dr. Bill Kynes

How can God be both good and powerful if evil exists? We live in a world where children die of cancer, women are raped,...

Listen